A rumor surfaced on November 13, 2026: Anthony Santander may never suit up for the Toronto Blue Jays again. If that turns out to be true, the Venezuelan outfielder will have played just 54 games on a five-year, $92.5 million contract — hitting .175 with a -1.0 WAR. That last number isn’t a typo. A negative WAR means he cost the team wins rather than adding them. And that’s only half the story.
Two Seasons, Two Different Disasters
Santander signed with Toronto in January 2025 off a legitimate All-Star campaign with the Baltimore Orioles: 44 home runs, 102 RBI, and a free-agent market that rewarded him accordingly. The Blue Jays were buying the right-handed bat they needed in the middle of their lineup.
What they couldn’t buy was health. In 2025, a left shoulder inflammation kept him out for nearly four months. He appeared in those 54 games, hit .175 with just 6 home runs and an OPS of .565 — well below the league-average OPS+ of 100. He made it back for the postseason but was pulled from the ALCS roster mid-series with back discomfort.
Then came 2026. In February, while ramping up his swing work, he suffered a setback and ended up having left labrum surgery. The original timeline was five to six months. The actual result: zero major league games all season. A September rehab stint with the Triple-A Buffalo Bisons was cut short by lower back tightness. The Blue Jays sent him to their player development complex in Dunedin, Florida, and officially shut him down for the year.
The Social Media Posts That Changed the Conversation
On November 4, 2026 — the day after Abdul El-Sayed became the first Muslim American elected to the U.S. Senate from Michigan — Santander posted a series of Islamophobic videos to his Instagram Story, including one featuring a Christian preacher claiming there is «no such thing as a kind Muslim.» He deleted them the next morning, but the screenshots were already out.
The organizational response was swift. GM Ross Atkins called the posts «extremely disappointing» at the GM Meetings on November 11. President Mark Shapiro issued a formal apology to the Muslim community on November 13, after meeting with community leaders. That same day, Santander posted his own apology on Instagram, acknowledging the content «caused harm and did not reflect his own convictions.»
No disciplinary action has been announced by the team as of this writing.
The local context matters. According to the 2021 Canadian census, 9.6% of Toronto’s population is Muslim — a fact that gives this controversy particular weight in the Blue Jays’ home market. The comparison being drawn widely on social media is to pitcher Anthony Bass, who was designated for assignment in 2023 after posting anti-LGBTQ content on Instagram. The situations aren’t identical: Bass was a reliever on a modest deal; Santander has three years and tens of millions of dollars still owed to him.
A Contract With No Clean Exit
Before the social media firestorm, GM Atkins had stated publicly that Toronto viewed Santander as part of their 2027 plans. That calculation now has a significant new variable.
- Designating him for assignment means eating the remaining money — a very different financial decision than what was done with Bass in 2023.
- Trading him would require finding a team willing to absorb that salary with two lost seasons on the ledger.
- Keeping him means navigating a live controversy in a market where it carries real weight.
For now, the rumor — first reported by @DanClarkSports — is exactly that: a rumor. No executive or credentialed reporter has confirmed a release, trade, or DFA. But the combination of compounding injuries, a heavy contract, and an active controversy in a sensitive market makes the question anything but far-fetched.
Santander is 32 years old and hasn’t faced a major league pitch since October 2025.

