On September 23, Ben Rice hit his 40th and 41st home runs of the season in a 9-2 Yankees win over Tampa Bay, taking sole possession of the AL home run lead. The number itself is impressive. Where it came from makes it remarkable.
Rice was the 363rd overall pick in the 2021 draft — a 12th-round catcher out of Dartmouth who had hit exactly one home run in his entire college career. Two seasons wiped out by COVID-19 had made him nearly invisible to scouts, who saw a player without a clear defensive position, not a future power hitter. The Yankees moved him to first base and DH, and let the work take care of the rest.
The result: .263/.362/.899 OPS, 97 RBI, 103 runs scored, and the AL home run lead with a week left in the regular season. Rice is now only the second player the Yankees ever drafted to hit 40 home runs in a season. The first was Aaron Judge — the 32nd overall pick in 2013, a first-round selection with every spotlight that comes with it. Rice got there 331 picks later, with none of that fanfare.
The Statcast Story Behind the Power
Rice isn’t running up home runs on volume alone. His Statcast profile tells the story of a hitter who earns every one of them:
- 654 plate appearances
- 41 home runs, 97 RBI
- AVG: .263 | OPS: .899
- xwOBA: .379 — 96th percentile in MLB
- Exit velocity: 91.8 mph — 89th percentile
- Barrel rate: 14.2% — 93rd percentile
- Hard-hit rate: 48% — 85th percentile
- Bat speed: 72.6 mph
- Chase rate discipline: 82nd percentile
Those aren’t fluky numbers. That’s an elite contact profile producing elite results — and it held up all season long, even with Aaron Judge spending most of the year on the injured list and Rice carrying the lineup without a safety net.
On September 23, his first homer was a 379-foot leadoff shot to right field against Mason Englert in the first inning — the fourth leadoff home run of his career. The second came in the fourth inning, 383 feet. Both put him in a three-way tie atop the AL leaderboard with Yordan Alvarez and Junior Caminero at 41.
There’s also a small detail worth noting: in spring training, manager Aaron Boone had publicly predicted Rice would hit 39 home runs this season. According to UPI’s coverage after the game, Boone acknowledged the prediction had stayed with Rice as motivation all year. He’s now two past that mark.
Schlittler Completes the Argument
Rice isn’t the only name in this story. Cam Schlittler, a 7th-round pick (220th overall) in the 2022 draft out of Northeastern University, is the other half of what’s becoming the Yankees’ most compelling organizational argument in years.
In 2026, Schlittler is 14-6 with a 1.94 ERA, 234 strikeouts, and just 47 walks across 32 starts. His ERA+ of 217 — measuring how far above league average his effectiveness sits — places him among the six best pitching seasons in the last 100 years at the minimum starts threshold. He’s the AL Cy Young frontrunner, though the award won’t be handed out until November and the race remains open.
His fWAR of 6.0 — six wins above a replacement-level pitcher — is tied with Jacob Misiorowski for the MLB lead among pitchers. That’s not a hot stretch. That’s a full season of sustained excellence from a player the rest of the league passed on for six rounds.
Two Late Picks. One Playoff Team.
The standard critique of the Yankees organization is that it buys championships rather than builds them. Gerrit Cole’s $324 million contract — he was the first overall pick in 2011 — fits that narrative perfectly. Rice and Schlittler don’t.
They’re the most concrete counterargument the franchise has produced in years: two college players the rest of the league let slide past the first ten rounds, developed into the AL home run leader and the most likely Cy Young winner. With Judge largely unavailable, those two kept New York in playoff position and in the conversation. That’s not something you can buy. That’s something you have to build.

