Max Muncy knows Shohei Ohtani as well as anyone in that clubhouse, and what he said on On Base with Mookie Betts cuts right to the heart of this October’s strangest storyline: the best player on the planet is entering the NLDS doing what he likes — not what he loves.
What Muncy Said
The episode of Bleacher Report’s On Base with Mookie Betts dropped on October 3, one day before Game 1 of the NLDS against the Atlanta Braves. Muncy wasn’t being dramatic. He was describing something any Dodgers teammate can feel when Ohtani talks about the mound.
«I think you would agree with this statement — Sho likes to hit, but he loves to pitch. He loves everything about pitching,» Muncy said. «He likes working at it. He likes talking about it.»
The distinction between likes and loves isn’t just word choice. It’s the difference between what Ohtani does well and what Ohtani needs. And right now, the thing he needs is on hold.
An .889 OPS Guy Who’d Rather Be on the Mound
To put this in perspective: Ohtani finished the regular season hitting .275/.377/.512 with 30 home runs in 139 games. His .889 OPS puts him among the most dangerous hitters in the league. His average exit velocity was 93.3 mph with a 16.4% barrel rate — elite-percentile numbers across all of MLB.
And yet, according to his own teammate, that’s basically autopilot for him. Pitching is where Ohtani puts his heart.
His last start came on July 3. He finished 8-2 with a 1.79 ERA and 95 strikeouts across 14 outings before a left knee and right biceps injury shut him down. He was placed on the IL retroactive to September 8 and returned only as a hitter. In his final five regular-season games he went 5-for-21 with 8 strikeouts — not his sharpest stretch, but his last batted balls showed exit velocities of 106.8, 106, and 103.9 mph, a sign the hard contact is coming back.
The Dodgers Need the Version He Takes for Granted
GM Brandon Gomes said on September 29 that Ohtani was «feeling really good physically» heading into the NLDS. The Dodgers, who went 100-62 and earned a first-round bye, have him penciled into the lineup from Game 1 against Atlanta at Dodger Stadium.
The paradox is real: a team chasing a three-peat is leaning on the Ohtani who, by his teammate’s own account, operates on cruise control at the plate. The pitcher — the one who talks pitching in the clubhouse, who spent months preparing to be a true two-way player as a Dodger for the first time, who threw six scoreless innings with 10 strikeouts in Game 4 of the 2025 NLCS — stays on the bench.
In his place: the .889 OPS designated hitter.
For the Dodgers, that’s still a massive weapon. But for Ohtani, this October feels different. His team is winning with the version of him he likes. The version he loves is watching from the dugout.

