Paul Skenes won the 2025 Cy Young with a 1.97 ERA and 7.7 WAR — essentially untouchable. In 2026, his ERA climbed to 2.89, he’s allowed 18 home runs, and his fastball is averaging 91.3 mph, landing at the 15th percentile in all of MLB. This week, Skenes said the World Baseball Classic played a role in his down year. An analyst pushed back immediately — and the numbers backed him up.
The WBC Argument and Why It Doesn’t Quite Hold Up
On September 21, Bleacher Report reported that Skenes partially attributed his velocity dip to the WBC, where he threw 4 shutout innings against Mexico and 4.1 innings allowing one run against the Dominican Republic — 8.1 total innings across two starts. The logic isn’t crazy: the tournament forces starters to ramp up hard in March, when they’d normally still be easing through spring training.
But Skenes himself walked it back. According to Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reporter Colin Beazley, Skenes said he «didn’t want to put it all on that» and acknowledged multiple factors were at play.
That’s where analyst @JacobBSpeaks raised a fair point: if the WBC were the main culprit, why is David Bednar — also on Team USA — dominating out of the Yankees bullpen with a .235 wOBA allowed per Statcast? And Eduardo Rodríguez, who started the tournament’s championship game for Venezuela, is showing real signs of a bounce-back in Arizona after back-to-back seasons with an ERA above 5.00. Two guys, same tournament, very different outcomes from Skenes.
The Mechanical Shift the Inning Count Can’t Explain
The deeper analysis points to something that has nothing to do with March. Skenes raised his arm angle from 23 degrees in 2024–25 to 26 degrees in 2026. That three-degree change altered the movement profile on his pitches. In 2025, hitters were missing his breaking balls by nearly 5 inches on average; this year that gap has shrunk to 3.6 inches. Less perceived movement, more hard contact.
The downstream effects are real:
- His ground-ball rate dropped from 51.1% to 39.7% — nearly 12 percentage points fewer batters rolling over, right where his defense could bail him out.
- He’s surrendered 18 home runs in 2026, more than his previous two seasons combined.
- His xERA sits at 4.3 — the first time in his career the expected number is more pessimistic than his actual ERA of 2.89, meaning the underlying contact quality is worse than the surface results show.
Analysis from Book Rule Bucs on Substack and MLB.com converge on the same mechanical red flags: a longer windup, greater extension, and a different push off the rubber. Those are the kinds of changes that 8.1 innings in March don’t produce on their own — and they wouldn’t affect a reliever like Bednar the same way they’d affect a starter logging 183-plus innings.
Rodríguez: Clean Counterexample or Argument With an Asterisk?
Arizona’s Eduardo Rodríguez is the most striking name in the counterargument. He not only played the WBC — he started the final that gave Venezuela the championship over the United States (3-2). And in 2026 he’s shown genuine improvement after two rough seasons.
The contrast with Skenes is hard to ignore. That said, context matters: Rodríguez was coming off two seasons with an ERA above 5.00, so his baseline for comparison was already low. And his xwOBA allowed in 2026 (.324) is actually worse than his real wOBA (.295), suggesting some of his strong results carry a bit of defensive and batted-ball luck. It’s not a clean argument in either direction.
The Honest Bottom Line
The WBC is a genuine risk — any time on the mound is. But pinning the decline of a reigning Cy Young winner entirely on 8.1 innings of tournament work, when his arm angle shifted three degrees and his pitch movement dropped across the board, is too convenient an explanation. The Pirates and Skenes himself have denied any injury. If there’s a real answer, his pitching mechanics have a lot more to say about it than the March calendar does.
Skenes by the Numbers in 2026
- Starts / IP: 31 starts, 183.2 innings
- ERA: 2.89 · WHIP: 1.23
- Strikeouts / Walks: 140 K, 62 BB (18.4% strikeout rate)
- xERA: 4.3
- Fastball: 91.3 mph avg, 2,287 rpm — 15th percentile in MLB
- Whiff rate: 21.9%
- Batting average against: .236
- Exit velocity allowed: 87.3 mph
- Barrel rate allowed: 7.5%
- Soft contact allowed: 81st percentile · Hard hit avoided: 86th percentile

