Félix Hernández is back on the Hall of Fame ballot, and he’s carrying the strongest case he’s had yet. Last year he went from 20.6% to 46.1% in BBWAA voting — a 25-point leap in a single cycle. The question now is whether that momentum is enough to clear the 75% threshold for Cooperstown, or whether The King needs at least one more trip around the ballot.
The Biggest Jump on the Ballot: From One-in-Five to Nearly Half
Few active candidates can point to growth this clean. Félix entered the HOF conversation in 2025 at 20.6% — a solid debut, but nowhere near the real debate. A year later he sat at 46.1%, the largest single-cycle percentage jump of any candidate that year.
For context: most eventual inductees show sustained growth of roughly 8 to 15 points per year during their peak momentum window. Félix doubled that pace. That doesn’t guarantee anything, but it tells you the voters who were on the fence are starting to come around.
Why His Career Divides Voters — and Why He’ll Probably Get There Anyway
The case against him has always been the same: 169 wins over 17 seasons isn’t the number you picture on a Cooperstown plaque. The case for him is that Félix spent the bulk of his career pitching for teams that almost never won, and his dominance numbers belong in a different conversation entirely.
- An ERA+ of 117 — meaning 17% better than the league-average pitcher, adjusted for park — sustained across more than 2,700 innings is Hall of Fame territory.
- His 2010 Cy Young season — a 2.27 ERA with 232 strikeouts in 249.2 innings — stands as one of the best individual pitcher seasons of the last generation. For a lot of voters, that peak alone earns the conversation.
The Seattle factor matters too. Félix is the most important pitcher in the history of a franchise that has never reached the World Series, and that kind of loyalty — 15 years in one uniform — moves votes inside the BBWAA.
How Many Points Does He Still Need?
From 46.1% to 75% is roughly 29 points. That’s a big jump for one cycle, but not unthinkable — Craig Biggio went from 39.3% to 68.2% between his second and third years on the ballot. The most likely outcome is that Félix lands somewhere between 55% and 65% this time around, which would set him up to cross the line in 2028.
The ballot itself helps. The 2027 class doesn’t carry the same weight of dominant first-time candidates as some recent years, which frees up space for in-progress candidates like Félix. Less direct competition for the writers who already have him on their list.
BBWAA results are announced in January. If the pace holds, King Félix will enter that night as the Latin American candidate with the most momentum on the ballot — and quite possibly the Venezuelan pitcher closest to Cooperstown since Johan Santana.

