On December 18, 2019, Gerrit Cole put pen to paper on the biggest contract of his career — and, at the time, the largest deal ever handed to a pitcher in baseball history: 9 years, $324 million guaranteed with the New York Yankees. That record held until Yoshinobu Yamamoto came along. Cole arrived in the Bronx at the peak of his powers, with Cy Young credentials and a mandate to bring a championship back to New York.
The Contract at a Glance
- Team: New York Yankees
- Signed: December 18, 2019
- Length: 9 years (2020–2028)
- Total guaranteed value: $324 million
- Average annual value: $36 million
- 2026 salary: $36 million
- No-trade clause: Yes
How the Deal Is Structured
The contract runs from 2020 through 2028 at a flat $36 million per season — no escalating bonuses, no deferred money, no complicated math. It’s the classic mega-deal formula in the majors: same check, every year, no surprises.
What makes this contract stand out beyond the dollar figure is the control Cole kept for himself. After the 2024 season, he held an opt-out that would have made him a free agent. He chose to stay. The two sides renegotiated, and Cole now has 4 years and $144 million remaining on his deal — still the unquestioned ace of the Yankees’ staff.
The Fine Print
Cole’s opt-out isn’t the only protection built into this contract. He also holds a full no-trade clause, giving him veto power over any potential deal. And because the contract is 100% guaranteed, the Yankees are on the hook for every dollar regardless of performance or health.
That guarantee was tested in March 2025, when Cole underwent Tommy John surgery — an operation that kept him off the mound but didn’t touch his paycheck. He collected every cent.
Where Cole Ranks Among the Best-Paid in the Game
- #14 — Largest contracts in MLB history (total guaranteed value)
- #3 — Among pitchers, all-time
- #10 — Highest average annual value among active 2026 contracts
- #9 — Highest single-season salary in 2026
- #12 — Most career earnings in MLB history
Rankings based on total guaranteed value, without discounting deferred money. Data from Spotrac and Baseball-Reference as of August 11, 2026.
Before the Yankees Deal
- Houston Astros, 2019: $13.5 million (arbitration)
Before New York came calling, Cole was already earning big-league money — $13.5 million through arbitration with Houston in 2019. But that was just the runway. The Yankees saw him as the missing piece and put a historic offer on the table.
Career Earnings
From his MLB debut through 2026, Cole has earned $264 million in salary. Add up every contract he’s ever signed and the total guaranteed figure reaches $338 million. The bulk of that comes from his Yankees deal, which remains the financial backbone of his career.
Career earnings include base salary, signing bonuses, and earned bonuses. They do not include endorsements or money from leagues outside the United States.

