The San Francisco Giants finished the 2026 season at 65-97 — their worst record since 2017 — and according to Jim Bowden, former MLB general manager and columnist at The Athletic, the organization should now be willing to listen to trade offers for every player on the roster. That includes franchise ace Logan Webb and designated hitter Rafael Devers, the two most valuable assets San Francisco has heading into this offseason.
What Bowden Said — and Why It Matters
Bowden’s assessment didn’t come out of nowhere. San Francisco ended the season with 24 players on the injured list — 17 of them on the 60-day IL, the highest total in all of MLB — and had to use 71 different players throughout the year, tying the all-time league record. All of this happened after the Giants entered 2026 carrying $451 million in combined commitments following the signings of Willy Adames and Matt Chapman, plus absorbing Rafael Devers’ full contract. The result: fourth place in the NL West and a fifth consecutive season without a playoff appearance.
Bowden wrote in his Athletic column: «I expect the Giants to listen to trade proposals for every player on their roster, including their ace Logan Webb and their best bat, Rafael Devers, because that’s the position the organization is in right now.» One important caveat: Bowden is an analyst and columnist, not a beat reporter with direct organizational sources. Giants president Buster Posey has not publicly confirmed this stance. Still, when a former GM of Bowden’s experience says even the untouchables should be available, it’s worth paying attention.
Webb: The One Clean Asset San Francisco Has
At the June trade deadline, Posey was explicit — Webb was not available. After 97 losses, that line looks a lot blurrier. Webb finished 2026 with an 8-9 record and a 4.31 ERA over 27 starts, a noticeable step back from his 3.22 ERA and NL-leading strikeout total in 2025. Two stints on the IL — right knee bursitis and a blister on his middle finger — disrupted his rhythm and cut his season short.
The contract is what makes Webb so attractive on the market. He signed a five-year, $90 million extension in April 2023, keeping him under team control through 2028 at a very reasonable rate for a three-time All-Star starter. That makes him the most coveted chip San Francisco could move — the kind of arm that could bring back an elite prospect or two in return.
The problem is that Webb is also the only reason a rebuilding project has an anchor. Without him, the Giants’ prospect pipeline isn’t deep enough to make a full teardown compelling. Posey’s real dilemma: if he commits to a genuine rebuild, trading Webb accelerates the timeline. If he bets on a contention window in 2027-28 with injured players returning, Webb is the centerpiece of that rotation. Both paths are valid. They’re also mutually exclusive.
Devers: The Bat Is Real, the Contract Is the Problem
Rafael Devers played 148 games in his first full season with San Francisco and posted a 3.6 bWAR — solid numbers anywhere, but not enough to lift a roster decimated by injuries. The quality of contact was elite all year long: his average exit velocity of 93 mph ranks in the 96th percentile in MLB, and his 51.6% hard-hit rate sits in the 94th percentile. There’s no question about what Devers can do when he makes contact.
The issue isn’t the bat. It’s the $211 million still owed over the next seven years — part of the 10-year, $313.5 million deal San Francisco took on in full when they acquired him from Boston in June 2025. Multiple analysts and rival team evaluators have noted that moving that contract is extremely difficult. For a Devers trade to work, the Giants would likely need to eat a significant chunk of salary or accept lower-tier prospects in return. Neither option is particularly appealing.
Posey did leave the door open for moving Devers — along with Chapman and Adames — at the deadline, but nothing materialized. Now, with another lost season in the books, the urgency is higher, but the contract math hasn’t changed.
Devers by the Numbers: What Statcast Says
The stats behind Devers’ 2026 season explain exactly why he shows up on every rival team’s radar:
- 633 plate appearances
- 37 home runs, 98 RBI
- AVG: .258 | OPS: .865
- xwOBA: .342 — what his contact quality says he should be producing
- Average exit velocity: 93 mph (96th percentile)
- Barrel rate: 12.5% (84th percentile)
- Hard-hit rate: 51.6% (94th percentile)
- Average bat speed: 71.9 mph
The Statcast profile is that of a middle-of-the-order force. The numbers validate him — the question is whether any team will take on what comes attached to them.
What Comes Next
San Francisco enters the offseason at a genuine crossroads. The Giants have the talent — at least in Webb and Devers — to be a meaningful trade partner. Whether Posey uses that leverage to restock a thin farm system or holds the core together for one more push remains the defining question of the winter. Either way, after 65 wins and a franchise-record 71 players used in a single season, standing pat isn’t really an option.

