On November 11, 2026, Scott Boras stepped to the mic at the GM Meetings in Las Vegas and someone asked the question everyone was thinking: is Max Scherzer done? Boras didn’t flinch. «If you saw his last game, you’ll understand he’s far from Max’d out.» A pun, sure — but also a calculated pitch to every front office in the room.
Scherzer is 42 years old, posted a 5.74 ERA over 18 starts and 84.2 innings with Toronto in 2026, and is now a free agent. On paper, that’s a tough sell. But Boras isn’t selling the ERA — he’s selling what Statcast saw underneath it.
The Start Boras Is Using as His Sales Pitch
On September 27, 2026, Scherzer took the mound at Rogers Centre for the Blue Jays‘ final regular-season game against the Reds. What followed looked nothing like a farewell: seven innings, six hits, one run, seven strikeouts, 114 pitches. Toronto won 5-1. When he walked off in the eighth, the crowd gave him a standing ovation. Scherzer went into the stands to hug his family. Most outlets covered it as a possible career finale.
Boras watched that game and turned it into Exhibit A. His logic: if a 42-year-old can pitch like that in the most emotionally loaded start of the season, the tank isn’t empty. It’s a fair point — even if the full-season numbers don’t scream «sign me.»
Why the 5.74 ERA Doesn’t Tell the Whole Story
The number every GM will see first is that 5.74 ERA — paired with a 1.33 WHIP and a 4-9 record. Not exactly a contract-inspiring line. But Statcast’s xERA of 4.24 — which measures expected effectiveness based on quality of contact allowed — sits nearly a run and a half lower. That gap suggests Scherzer ran into bad luck on batted balls, not a pitcher getting shelled.
Dig into the contact numbers and the case gets stronger:
- Exit velocity allowed: 87.4 mph — hitters aren’t squaring him up
- Hard-hit rate avoided: 84th percentile in MLB — top quarter among all pitchers
- Soft contact allowed: 78th percentile
- Barrel rate: 8.1%
- Whiff rate: 21.3% of swings
- Opponents hit just .240 against him
- Fastball sitting at 92.4 mph with 2,357 RPM of spin
He also spent time on the IL in June with back spasms, which dragged down his overall numbers. When healthy in the second half, the flashes were real: on August 30 he blanked the Mariners over seven innings on one hit with 10 strikeouts. CBS Sports called it «turning back the clock.»
The Bigger Picture: Boras, a Lockout, and a Hall of Fame Resume
Boras isn’t just managing Scherzer’s market here. The current CBA expires December 1, 2026, with a lockout expected the following day — meaning teams have fewer than three weeks to get deals done before the freeze hits. Boras, who also represents Tarik Skubal (the hottest name on the market), has every incentive to keep all his clients moving at once.
Scherzer finished 2026 on a one-year, $3 million deal with Toronto, plus $1 million in incentives for reaching 65 innings (hit September 11) and another $1 million for surpassing 75 innings (hit September 23). He earned what was in the contract. Now his agent is in full campaign mode.
And the career context matters. Scherzer has 3,557 career strikeouts — top ten all-time in MLB history. For a pitcher with that kind of standing, one rough season at 42 doesn’t automatically close the door. Boras knows the name carries weight. And he knows a 4.24 xERA gives him something real to put on the table.

