On the final day of the regular season, the Toronto Blue Jays posted a tweet about Max Scherzer that said what everyone in baseball already knows: «One day, Cooperstown will call his name.» The context makes it hit harder: Scherzer just wrapped up a season with a 6.14 ERA and a -0.6 WAR — the only negative WAR of his 19-year career. The worst season of his life doesn’t change where he’s headed.
A Rough Year Doesn’t Erase What He Built
Scherzer arrived in Toronto before the 2025 season at 41 years old, and plenty of people treated it like a farewell tour. Instead, he ended up starting Game 7 of the 2025 World Series against the Dodgers — 4⅓ innings, one run allowed, before the Blue Jays fell in 11 innings. Not the ending he deserved, but exactly the stage that great pitchers find.
He signed on for one more year in Toronto in 2026. It was a grind for him and for the team: the Blue Jays finished 78-83, knocked out of postseason contention the week before after a doubleheader loss to the Baltimore Orioles. Scherzer went 3-9 with a 6.14 ERA in 77.2 innings.
For perspective: from 2013 to 2022, he threw 1,877.1 innings with a 2.78 ERA. One number doesn’t cancel the other, but you need both on the table.
The Blue Jays’ tweet went out on September 27, 2026 — Game 162 — during Fan Appreciation Weekend at Rogers Centre as the franchise celebrated its 50th anniversary. It wasn’t a retirement announcement: Scherzer said the previous Saturday that he’ll decide on 2027 during the offseason. But the tone from the organization says everything without saying it.
Why Cooperstown Is as Certain as It Looks
Scherzer’s Hall of Fame credentials don’t need defending — just organizing:
- Three Cy Young Awards (2013, 2016, 2017)
- Eight All-Star selections
- Two World Series titles
- 3.22 career ERA over 19 seasons
- 3,550 career strikeouts — currently fighting for eighth all-time alongside Justin Verlander, who announced his retirement the day before (Saturday, September 26) after his own Game 161
Verlander sits at 3,560 career strikeouts. Scherzer is at 3,550. Two pitchers who sharpened each other for years in the American League, who shared a rotation in Detroit, and who are now leaving the game almost simultaneously with nearly identical Hall of Fame résumés. Baseball rarely gives you parallels that clean.
The 2026 season won’t be featured prominently on his plaque in Cooperstown. What will be: the kind of pitcher he was during the most dominant decade of his career, when he struck out 10 batters per nine innings and led the league in wins four times. That’s the Scherzer the Blue Jays are honoring with their tweet.
The Numbers Behind the ERA
Scherzer’s 2026 ERA looks worse than how he actually pitched — Statcast backs that up. Here’s the full picture across 18 starts and 77.2 innings:
- ERA: 6.14 · WHIP: 1.33
- Strikeouts: 61 · Walks: 34 (18.1% strikeout rate)
- xERA: 4.35 (expected ERA based on contact quality allowed)
- Average fastball: 92.4 mph at 2,354 rpm
- Whiff rate: 20.4%
- Batting average against: .240
- Exit velocity allowed: 87.4 mph
- Barrel rate allowed: 8.8%
How that stacks up across MLB:
- Whiff %: 11th percentile (among the lowest in the league)
- Soft contact allowed: 78th percentile
- Hard contact avoided: 83rd percentile
The ERA is real. So is the gap between that number and what the underlying data says he deserved. Both things are true at once — which is a fitting way to close out a career this complicated and this great.

