Tarik Skubal has back-to-back Cy Young Awards, a 2.79 ERA in 2026, and is now a Dodger chasing a championship. But what people will remember about his departure from Detroit isn’t any of those numbers. It’s that he cried saying goodbye to his teammates in the clubhouse — and that he didn’t shed a single tear on his wedding day. The 29-year-old left-hander said so himself on a podcast just days after the August 2 trade, and the quote spread across baseball social media within hours.
The story nobody expected from a two-time Cy Young winner
Skubal has been part of the Tigers organization for nine years. Detroit drafted him in the 9th round of the 2018 draft — pick No. 255, with a $350,000 bonus — and he made his MLB debut in August 2020. He stuck with the team through some lean years before becoming one of the two or three best starters on the planet. That kind of bond doesn’t dissolve with a press release.
«A lot of those guys are my best friends, and it’s a bunch of men and I’m crying. I hate crying. I don’t cry a lot. When my wife…» — he said on the podcast, leaving the sentence hanging.
The context was unmistakable. His wife Jessica, his girlfriend since high school in Kingman, Arizona, walked down the aisle on November 23, 2021 without pulling a single tear out of him. His clubhouse did.
The numbers that explain why Detroit hurts and the Dodgers celebrate
To understand the weight of this trade, you have to look at what walked out the door. During his two Cy Young seasons (2024 and 2025), Skubal went 31-10 with a 2.30 ERA and 469 strikeouts in 387⅓ innings. His combined 12.6 WAR over those two years, per FanGraphs, was the highest of any pitcher in MLB during that span — meaning he delivered the equivalent of more than 12 wins above a replacement-level arm across two seasons.
In 2026, before the trade, he was still locked in: 2.79 ERA, 116 strikeouts in 16 starts, and a July stretch of five outings with a 2.03 ERA and 41 strikeouts in 31 innings. Statcast backed it up — opponents averaged just 86.9 mph exit velocity against him, with a 7.4% Barrel rate. Hitters weren’t squaring him up even when they made contact.
In return, Detroit received three Dodgers prospects:
- Zyhir Hope, outfielder (No. 5 in the LA system)
- River Ryan, pitcher (No. 7)
- Brady Smith, pitcher (No. 17)
The package has split opinion. Some analysts call it fair given that Skubal is a pure rental — he hits free agency after 2026. Others, especially Tigers fans, feel Detroit sold low. There’s no consensus. What is clear is what comes next on the open market: Skubal is widely expected to sign the largest contract ever given to a starting pitcher, potentially topping the 12-year, $325 million deal Yoshinobu Yamamoto signed with — you guessed it — the Dodgers. Perfect irony.
Skubal defends the Dodgers and says he wants to come back to Detroit
Before anyone assumes Skubal left bitter, he made his feelings clear. When critics accused the Dodgers of «ruining baseball» with their financial firepower, he pushed back: any organization could have built what LA built. That’s not an LA problem — it’s a model other teams chose not to follow.
And in that same podcast, he said he’d like to return to Detroit as a free agent. Both things coexist without contradiction: he’s grateful for the shot to win with a Dodgers team going for a third straight title, and he still considers Michigan home.
That’s what gives the wedding anecdote its real weight. Skubal didn’t cry because he was forced out or because he’s unhappy — he cried because nine years in Detroit built something that no stat line fully captures. A 12.6 WAR doesn’t explain why a 29-year-old left-hander breaks down in front of a room full of grown men in an American League clubhouse. For that, you need the whole story.

