On September 19, 2026, with the Yankees already in the postseason (88-64) and the Diamondbacks fighting for their lives (80-73), Anthony Volpe did something nobody in the stadium saw coming: he intentionally let a pop-up drop to try to retire the runner at second base. It wasn’t an error. It was pure tactics — and MLB has a rule that’s been on the books for over a hundred years designed specifically to stop that from working. Here’s why, this time, it was completely legal.
Why Letting a Pop-Up Drop on Purpose Is Sometimes Legal
The Infield Fly Rule dates back to 1895. The National League introduced it precisely to stop infielders from intentionally dropping routine pop-ups with runners on first and second (or bases loaded) to set up cheap double plays. Under the rule, the umpire can declare the batter automatically out and leave runners free to advance at their own risk — stripping the defender of any tactical advantage.
But there’s one detail that changes everything: the rule only applies when there are runners on first and second, or the bases are loaded, with fewer than two outs. If there’s only a runner on second — nobody on first — the Infield Fly Rule simply doesn’t apply. That opens the door for an infielder to intentionally let the ball drop, pick it up, and throw to second to retire the runner who tried to advance.
That’s exactly what Volpe attempted.
Official Rule 5.09(a)(12) fills in the rest of the picture: if an infielder intentionally drops a fair fly ball with first and second occupied, or bases loaded, and fewer than two outs, the batter is out, the ball is dead, and runners return to their bases. Outside that specific scenario, the tactic is perfectly legal — and it can be devastating if the baserunner doesn’t read it in time.
Volpe at Second Base: The Defensive Experiment That’s Saving His Season
That Volpe was even in position to pull off that play isn’t a coincidence. On September 19, the 25-year-old shortstop was playing second base — not his natural position — as part of a defensive experiment the Yankees put in motion when Jazz Chisholm Jr. landed on the injured list with a right thumb sprain. George Lombard Jr. slid over to cover shortstop; Volpe moved to the middle of the infield.
The shift came at exactly the right moment. Volpe had been sent down to Triple-A Scranton mid-season after a rough start, but he returned on the expanded roster looking like a different player: .276 average, 1.008 OPS, and 8 home runs in 23 games with Scranton before his recall. The intentional drop against Arizona fits the same story — a player who came back smarter, more comfortable, and with more tools in the bag.
The Yankees’ starter that day, Cam Schlittler, came in with a 1.95 ERA and 0.90 WHIP on the season — one of the most reliable arms on the staff over the last few months. New York had already won the series opener 9-2 on Friday the 18th, with a postseason berth safely in hand. Arizona, meanwhile, needed to win nearly everything left on the schedule just to see October.
The Numbers Behind Volpe’s 2026
Anthony Volpe’s Statcast numbers in 2026 tell the story that traditional stats don’t always capture:
- 223 plate appearances in 2026
- 2 home runs, 26 RBI
- AVG: .247 | OPS: .670
- xwOBA: .296 (what his quality of contact says he should be producing)
- Average exit velocity: 88.2 mph
- Barrel rate: 4.7%
- Hard-hit rate: 37.7% (balls hit at 95+ mph)
- Sprint speed: 77th percentile league-wide
The gap between his .670 OPS and his .296 xwOBA suggests Volpe has been getting less out of his contact than he deserves. The Triple-A stint — and that heads-up play against the Diamondbacks — hint that the adjustment may already be underway.

