The New York Yankees have a real hole at second base and they’re already working the market. According to Jim Bowden of The Athletic, the Bronx Bombers have been connected to both Brandon Lowe and Luis Arraez — two of the best free-agent second basemen available this offseason. And the door hasn’t fully closed on a reunion with Jazz Chisholm Jr. either. Three options, three completely different profiles, and one decision that will say a lot about how seriously Brian Cashman is taking 2027.
The hole Chisholm left — and what Cashman said
Jazz Chisholm Jr. manned second base for the Yankees in 2026 and finished the year as the best second baseman on the free-agent market, posting a 7.8 WAR — nearly eight wins above a replacement-level player. New York didn’t extend him a qualifying offer, which officially opened the vacancy and sparked interest from at least ten other teams.
GM Brian Cashman didn’t sugarcoat things at the General Managers Meetings in Las Vegas, calling second base «another area of uncertainty» and acknowledging the team is in information-gathering mode before making any moves. Translation: they don’t know what they’re doing yet, but they know they have to do something.
That’s where Bowden’s report comes in. The former GM and Athletic analyst wrote that «the Yankees have also been connected to second basemen Brandon Lowe and Luis Arraez, and the door has not yet closed on a reunion with Jazz Chisholm Jr.» These are early-offseason exploratory contacts — no confirmed formal negotiations — but the fact that two such different names are on the table says something about what the front office is weighing.
Lowe vs. Arraez: same position, different universes
Brandon Lowe, 32, just had the best season of his career with the Pittsburgh Pirates: .260/.331/.493, 35 home runs, 96 RBI in 150 games, and a 4.9 fWAR. He bats left-handed, which at Yankee Stadium is practically an architectural advantage — that short porch in right field was built for left-handed hitters. Lowe fits the power-bat profile New York has always prioritized in its lineup.
Luis Arraez is a different planet entirely. The 29-year-old Venezuelan closed 2026 hitting .310/.345 with just 28 strikeouts in 655 plate appearances — that’s striking out less than once every 23 at-bats, a genuine rarity in today’s game. He also improved his glove, posting 12 Outs Above Average at second base. Arraez is a three-time batting champion (2022, 2023, 2024) and a four-time All-Star. He’s the exact antidote to the strikeout problem that hurt the Yankees badly in the AL Division Series.
This isn’t about who’s the better player — it’s about which problem the Yankees want to solve. Lowe adds offensive explosion. Arraez adds contact quality and consistency. The second-base market this winter also includes Gleyber Torres, Jeff McNeil, and Xavier Edwards, so Cashman has plenty of options. The catch is that they come with very different price tags in both years and dollars.
Why this decision matters beyond one roster spot
The Yankees do have internal options — Anthony Volpe, José Caballero, and Luis García Jr. — but none has made a convincing case as a long-term starter. Signing a meaningful free agent at second base isn’t just filling a gap; it’s a signal of how aggressively Cashman plans to reshape this roster.
- If they go with Lowe, the Yankees are betting on more power in a lineup that already hits home runs but strikes out too much.
- If they go with Arraez, they’re admitting that October’s problem wasn’t a lack of distance — it was a lack of contact when it mattered most.
- If the Chisholm door really is still open, they could end up paying the highest price on the market for a player they already had — which has its own logic if what they’re after is certainty.
For now, it’s all exploration. But the direction this decision takes over the next few weeks will say a lot about which Yankees team shows up in the Bronx next April.

