Dustin May’s market didn’t just heat up — it exploded. In a matter of days, the number of interested teams jumped from four to nine: the Cubs, Nationals, Orioles, Giants, Reds, Guardians, Marlins, White Sox, and Blue Jays are all in play for the 29-year-old right-hander, according to Jim Bowden of The Athletic on November 15. His 4.70 ERA from 2026 tells one story. His 3.63 FIP — which filters out what he couldn’t control, like defense and hit-timing luck — tells a completely different one. That gap is exactly why nine clubs are at the table.
Why Nine Teams Are Jumping On Board
Bowden put it plainly on X: «The market for Dustin May is blowing up right now with the Cubs, Nationals, Orioles, Giants, Reds, Guardians, Marlins, White Sox and Blue Jays all in play right now!!!» — and that sentence captures the offseason moment perfectly. The youngest and most affordable starting pitcher on the market has become the focal point for clubs with very different needs.
All nine share one denominator: they need starters for 2027. The Cubs lost rotation pieces to free agency. The Guardians have at least one open spot in their rotation. The Nationals, Marlins, and White Sox are in rebuild mode and hunting calculated-risk arms. The Orioles and Giants want proven pitchers for legitimate contention. The Reds are drawn to May’s ground-ball tendencies — a 44% ground-ball rate in the first half of 2026 is a natural fit for Great American Ball Park, which punishes fly-ball pitchers. The Blue Jays are in the mix, though some analysts see them targeting a higher-end arm.
Worth noting: just four days before Bowden’s report, Jon Morosi of MLB Network had only four teams on the radar — Cubs, White Sox, Padres, and Astros. The jump to nine in less than a week isn’t a coincidence. It’s a sign that May’s agent is actively working the market to create competition and drive up the price.
The ERA Is Misleading — Here’s What the Real Numbers Say
The case for May doesn’t start with his results line — it starts with what’s underneath it. In 2026 he threw 145.2 innings with a 4.70 ERA and a 1.32 WHIP — back-of-the-rotation numbers on the surface. But his 3.63 FIP ranked him 50th among qualified MLB starters. A gap of more than a full run between ERA and FIP typically signals bad luck, poor defense behind the pitcher, or both.
The timing of his struggles matters too. He arrived in Milwaukee mid-season via trade from the Cardinals and posted a 5.65 ERA in his first ten starts with the Brewers — 23 earned runs in 36.2 innings. That scared some people off. But his FIP in that same stretch was considerably lower, and he ultimately found his footing as a reliever in the postseason, where the Brewers won the first World Series title in franchise history.
FanGraphs projects a two-year, $30 million deal for May this winter — well below the nine-figure territory being discussed for the top starters on the market. That’s the appeal: if his process numbers translate into results, whoever signs him will have paid second-tier prices for mid-rotation production.
The Risk Is Real — And Worth Naming
May is 29 years old with two Tommy John surgeries on his record (2021 and 2023) and a documented inconsistency that goes beyond bad luck. He’s not a proven ace. His postseason with Milwaukee went for 7 earned runs in 11 bullpen innings. His appeal is built on potential and age, not established excellence.
Last offseason he signed a one-year, $12.5 million deal with the Cardinals. This time, with nine teams in the room, the market is going to look very different. The question is whether someone gives him the two years FanGraphs projects — or whether a club sees enough upside to go a little further.
The Numbers Behind the Name
May’s fastball is one you feel, and Statcast backs it up. His full 2026 stat line:
- 31 starts, 145.2 innings
- ERA: 4.70 · WHIP: 1.32
- 144 strikeouts, 50 walks (23.2% strikeout rate)
- xERA: 4.45
- Fastball: 95.6 mph avg, 2,387 rpm spin rate
- Whiff rate: 23% of swings
- Batting average against: .256
- Exit velocity allowed: 90 mph
- Barrel rate allowed: 7.8%
How he stacks up across MLB:
- Fastball velocity: 85th percentile
- Soft contact allowed: 14th percentile (one of the lowest in MLB)
- Hard-hit rate allowed: 7th percentile (one of the lowest in MLB)
With a curveball in the 98th percentile in spin rate across all of MLB, the raw stuff isn’t in question. What’s in question is whether he can stay on the mound.

