The Chicago White Sox have their first big move of the winter: Dustin May has signed a three-year, $52.5 million contract, confirmed by ESPN and May’s agent Craig Rose. He arrives as the starter with the most dramatic injury history on the market — two Tommy John surgeries, a ruptured esophagus — and a 3.63 FIP that explains far better than his ERA why nine teams were chasing him.
The number that matters: 3.63 FIP when the ERA said 4.70
Early reports had the deal at $50 million, but the final confirmed figure from ESPN and agent Craig Rose to Jon Heyman landed at $52.5 million total. That’s not a minor footnote — it’s the largest contract signed by a White Sox player this winter, and they gave it to a pitcher who finished 2026 with a 4.70 ERA.
So why pay that? Because the ERA is a little misleading. May split the season between the St. Louis Cardinals (21 starts, 4.38 ERA) and the Milwaukee Brewers (10 starts, 5.65 ERA after the August trade deadline), but his FIP of 3.63 — which measures what he directly controlled: strikeouts, walks and home runs — sat a full run below his ERA. His HR/fly ball rate of 9.2% was the lowest of his career in any season with more than 100 innings pitched.
Chicago didn’t buy the ERA. They bought what’s underneath it.
In total, May made 31 starts in 2026 — a career high — and threw 145.2 innings with 144 strikeouts. His fastball still averages 97 mph. Given everything his elbows have been through, that’s remarkable.
Two Tommy Johns, a ruptured esophagus and a ring along the way
To understand why $52.5 million sounds like a gamble and still makes sense, you have to know the backstory. May was one of the Dodgers’ top prospects in the late 2010s: in his first 31 major league appearances he posted a 2.93 ERA and won a World Series ring with LA in 2020.
Then came the injuries:
- May 2021: First Tommy John surgery. He missed the rest of that season and nearly all of the next.
- July 2023: A flexor tendon rupture required a revision of the Tommy John procedure. He missed all of 2024.
- Mid-2024: A ruptured esophagus sent him back to the operating table for the third time in three years.
He returned in 2025 with the Dodgers and later the Boston Red Sox, then signed a one-year, $12.5 million deal with St. Louis for 2026. After being dealt to Milwaukee at the August deadline, he finished the year as a World Series champion with the Brewers — though his mutual option was declined after the season.
Now he has his second ring and the longest contract of his career.
What it means for the White Sox: patching the thinnest rotation in baseball
Chicago returned to the postseason in 2026 after years of rebuilding, but they did it leaning heavily on the bullpen — their starters threw the fewest innings of any rotation in the majors during the regular season. That’s the specific hole May is being brought in to fill.
The plan is for May to slot near the top of a rotation that currently projects Sean Burke and Davis Martin as the other confirmed starters. At 29 years old with a fastball that still touches 97, the logic is straightforward: if the body holds up, Chicago has a front-of-the-rotation arm it never had during the rebuild years.
This signing is also the second notable move of the winter connected to the champion Brewers: ALCS MVP Jake Bauers earlier signed a four-year deal with the Boston Red Sox. Milwaukee is losing pieces from its title run; Chicago is picking them up.

