San Diego lost seven starters in less than a week and currently has Randy Vásquez as the only guaranteed arm in their 2027 rotation. That’s the backdrop for one of the more intriguing free-agent rumors of the offseason: the Padres are emerging as a potential landing spot for Nick Martinez, the right-hander who just turned in the best season of his career with the Tampa Bay Rays.
In 2026, Martinez made his first All-Star team, posted a 3.10 ERA over 180 innings, and started Game 1 of the World Series. This isn’t a sentimental fan wish — it’s a market-driven story with real logic behind it.
Why a Reunion Makes Sense for San Diego
The Padres’ rotation was a chronic problem in 2026. They ranked fourth-worst in MLB in innings pitched by starters and posted a collective 4.42 ERA from the rotation. The offseason has only made things worse: Michael King is a free agent, Brett de Pivetta’s option was declined, and Joe Musgrove — who hasn’t started a regular-season game since 2024 — is still working his way back from Tommy John surgery.
GM A.J. Preller has publicly named starting pitching as the number-one priority this offseason. Martinez, who already knows the organization, the stadium, and the uniform, fits the profile Preller has historically chased: a pitcher who suppresses hard contact and works with the defense behind him.
Martinez spent the 2022 and 2023 seasons in San Diego, initially as a swingman and high-leverage reliever. He signed a 3-year, $26 million deal in November 2022 before declining his player option in 2023 and heading to Tampa. He’d be coming back in a very different role — a proven mid-rotation starter with a 15-win season on his résumé.
There’s also a market angle worth noting: Martinez is not eligible to receive a qualifying offer because he already received one in 2025, meaning any team that signs him won’t forfeit a draft pick. Per JustBaseball projections, he’s expected to land around 2 years and $32 million (~$16M AAV). For the Padres, who are already projecting close to $180 million in 2027 payroll with 15 players under contract before adding a single starter, that number is workable — if the return is a legitimate top-third-of-the-rotation arm.
The 2026 Martinez Is Not the One Who Left San Diego
To be precise: the Martinez who was in San Diego in 2022–23 was a useful, mixed-role pitcher — not a dominant starter. The 2026 version is different in results, even if the underlying profile hasn’t changed dramatically.
His fastball averages 91.4 mph — modest velocity, sitting in the 20th percentile in MLB — and his strikeout rate is among the lowest in the league (K% in the 4th percentile). He doesn’t overpower hitters. What made his 2026 season special was elite command and contact management.
His walk rate ranked in the 100th percentile among qualified starters — the best control in the majors. Only 3.6% of batters he faced drew a walk. And when hitters did make contact, they hit it soft: he allowed an average exit velocity of 87 mph, with his hard-hit-allowed rate sitting in the 88th percentile and soft contact generated in the 86th percentile.
Hitters batted .249 against him, but his xERA of 3.98 — what the model expects given the quality of contact he allowed — suggests some regression risk that interested teams will factor in. For a Padres organization that has historically built its rotation around contact suppression and defense, though, that profile is far from foreign.
Martinez by the Numbers — 2026 Statcast
- 31 starts, 180.0 innings pitched
- ERA: 3.10 · WHIP: 1.09
- 109 strikeouts, 26 walks (15.1% K rate)
- xERA: 3.98
- Fastball: 91.4 mph at 2,301 rpm
- Whiff rate: 17.4%
- Batting average against: .249
- Exit velocity allowed: 87 mph
- Barrel rate allowed: 6.8%
How He Stacks Up League-Wide
- K%: 4th percentile (among the lowest in MLB)
- BB%: 100th percentile (best control in the majors)
- Whiff%: 2nd percentile (among the lowest in MLB)
- Soft contact generated: 86th percentile
- Hard hit avoided: 88th percentile
Martinez doesn’t miss bats. He doesn’t throw hard. But he doesn’t walk anyone, and he doesn’t let you square one up either. For a Padres team that desperately needs rotation innings and has a GM who knows exactly what Martinez brings, the fit is hard to argue with.

