CC Sabathia spent eleven seasons pitching against the Red Sox as the face of the Yankees‘ rotation. Now he’s in the Hall of Fame, watching the game from the outside — and what he sees in Payton Tolle clearly impresses him, whether any New York fan wants to hear it or not.
In comments reported by Pete Abraham in the Boston Globe, Sabathia put the 23-year-old Red Sox right-hander at the top of the league for his arsenal. More than that, he admitted Tolle has something he never quite had himself: the ability to pitch ice-cold, no matter the moment.
The compliment nobody expected from a Yankee
Context matters here. Sabathia didn’t say this on a quiet November afternoon. He said it days after the Yankees swept the Red Sox in the 2026 AL Wild Card Series (2-0) — a series in which Tolle started Game 1 at Yankee Stadium, held them to one run over four innings, and watched his bullpen implode in a 9-0 loss. A 23-year-old making his postseason debut, on the road, against the most intimidating opponent in the bracket — and he walked off with his head up.
Sabathia’s words, as reported by Boston Globe Sports:
«I love watching him, and I love his personality. I don’t think I could have pitched the way he does. I was always way more emotional and upset… He’s top of the league as far as his arsenal goes. I love how he attacks hitters. When you have that kind of stuff, you have to pitch in the zone, and he seems to understand that.»
That last part is the key. Sabathia admires that Tolle doesn’t nibble at the edges or hide his pitches — he puts them in the zone and trusts his movement and velocity to do the work. It’s a philosophy Sabathia says took him years to learn, if he ever fully mastered it at all.
Three fastballs, one idea: attack
What Sabathia describes has a Statcast signature. Tolle throws a four-seamer, a cutter, and a sinker — three fastball variants — roughly 90% of the time, and hitters still can’t square him up. His heater averages 94.1 mph (69th percentile in velocity), which isn’t elite by raw numbers. But his chase rate sits in the 96th percentile — meaning almost nobody in MLB gets hitters to swing at pitches outside the zone as consistently as Tolle does.
The results in his first full big-league season:
- 26 starts, 148.2 innings
- ERA: 3.03 · WHIP: 1.10
- 171 strikeouts against 40 walks (28.4% K rate, 86th percentile)
- xERA: 2.70 — suggesting even a 3.03 ERA was a touch more than he deserved to give up
- Opponents batting .222; xwOBA against in the 95th percentile
- Average exit velocity allowed: 87.6 mph; barrel rate allowed: 6%
Two moments from 2026 stand out. On September 13, Tolle threw an immaculate inning against the Royals — nine pitches, three strikeouts. On August 7, he struck out 14 batters in six innings against the Athletics, becoming the youngest Red Sox pitcher to do that since Roger Clemens.
These aren’t the numbers of a promising kid. They’re the numbers of a pitcher who already knows what he’s doing.
Third in AL Rookie of the Year voting — in a loaded class
Tolle finished third in the 2026 AL Rookie of the Year balloting. The winner was Kevin McGonigle of the Tigers, followed by Parker Messick of the Guardians (12-9, 2.56 ERA, 193 strikeouts). In most rookie classes, Tolle wins that award. In this one, he finished third with a real case.
He was a second-round pick in the 2024 MLB Draft (50th overall) by Boston, signed for $2 million, and made his big-league debut on August 29, 2025. One year later, a Hall of Famer is calling him one of the best in the game. That’s not a normal development arc for a second-round pick.
For reference: Sabathia won 251 games, struck out 3,093 batters, took home the 2007 Cy Young, made six All-Star teams, and was elected to the Hall of Fame in 2025 on his first ballot. He doesn’t throw compliments around casually. When he says Tolle is top of the league, he means it.

