Payton Tolle will take the mound at Yankee Stadium on Tuesday, September 29, for Game 1 of the American League Wild Card — and the history he’s stepping into is not small. At 23 years and 332 days old, he becomes just the third-youngest pitcher in Red Sox history to start the first game of a playoff run. Only Smoky Joe Wood (22 years, 349 days in the 1912 World Series) and Babe Ruth (23 years, 211 days in the 1918 World Series) were younger. The stat was surfaced by Sarah Langs (@SlangsOnSports) on September 28, 2026.
Wood went 34-5 with a 1.91 ERA that year and won three games in the Series. Ruth threw 17 innings in 1918 and allowed just 2 earned runs. Tolle walks into that company without anyone having planned it — and without the company being anything to shrug at.
Why the Decision Makes Sense
Manager Chad Tracy went with Tolle over Sonny Gray for Game 1, a call that raised eyebrows. Gray finished the season 18-5 with a 2.72 ERA at age 36 in his first year in Boston, and he’ll get Game 2. Ranger Suárez is lined up for a potential Game 3. But Tracy had a clear reason to go with the rookie first.
In two regular-season starts against the Yankees in 2026, Tolle went 1-0 with a 0.69 ERA, a 0.538 WHIP, 18 strikeouts and just 3 walks in 13 innings. New York hitters batted .093 against him in those two outings. On June 26, he retired the first 16 Yankees in order and finished with one hit allowed over seven scoreless innings. That’s not a fluke: Statcast clocked his average exit velocity allowed at 87.6 mph — the lower that number, the softer hitters are making contact — and his barrel rate allowed sat at just 6%. Over his final three regular-season starts, he posted a 1.53 ERA with 24 strikeouts in 17.2 innings. The rookie is rolling.
The Full 2026 Statcast Picture
Across 26 starts and 148.2 innings in 2026, here’s what Tolle’s numbers look like:
- ERA: 3.03 · WHIP: 1.10
- Strikeouts: 171 · Walks: 40 (28.4% strikeout rate)
- xERA: 2.70 — 95th percentile in MLB
- Opponents’ batting average: .222
- Average exit velocity allowed: 87.6 mph
- Barrel rate allowed: 6% (77th percentile)
- Whiff rate: 27.9%
- Fastball: 94.1 mph average, 2,289 rpm spin rate
- xwOBA against: 95th percentile (elite)
The Guy Waiting on the Other Side
This is not the easy matchup. Tolle will face Cam Schlittler, who led the American League with a 1.95 ERA and racked up 239 strikeouts on a 14-6 record. Against Boston specifically, Schlittler posted a 0.74 ERA with 27 strikeouts in 24.1 innings across four starts. Last year, he was dominant in the Yankees’ three-game sweep of the Red Sox in the Wild Card round.
That matchup is exactly what pushed Tracy to play his best card against New York — and Tolle, against these Yankees, has been his best card.
One More Variable
Aaron Judge returned from injury on September 8 but landed back on the injured list with a right calf strain just before the postseason. His availability for Game 1 hasn’t been officially ruled out, but if he can’t go, the lineup Tolle carved up in June arrives incomplete.
This is the seventh time in history that the Red Sox and Yankees have met in the postseason. The winner advances to face the Tampa Bay Rays — the AL’s No. 1 seed with a first-round bye — in the ALDS.

