Nobody in baseball is better positioned to settle this debate than Dave Roberts. He played alongside Barry Bonds with the Giants in 2007. He manages Shohei Ohtani with the Dodgers today. And when the ‘6-1-1’ podcast on MLB.com asked him to weigh in, Roberts didn’t dodge: Ohtani is, by far, the best player he’s ever seen. But the full quote — the one the viral clip cut short — carries a distinction that actually changes the conversation.
What Roberts Said, Word for Word
Roberts was genuinely respectful about Bonds. He called him «the greatest position player I ever played with» and acknowledged that nobody did what Bonds did in the batter’s box. Then he put Ohtani on a different floor entirely.
The distinction matters. Roberts is not claiming Ohtani is a better hitter than Bonds — that’s a hard argument to make against a man with 762 career home runs, 73 in a single season (2001), and 7 MVP awards. What he’s saying is that Ohtani, as a complete player, operates at a level he’s simply never witnessed before. And the key difference he points to isn’t the bat. It’s the mound.
The Numbers That Make the Argument for Themselves
In the 2026 season, Ohtani hit .275/.377/.512 with 30 home runs, 81 RBI, and 11 stolen bases. As a starter, he posted a 1.79 ERA over 85.2 innings with 95 strikeouts and an 8-0 record. Two roles, one person, elite numbers in both.
For context: across his 22 MLB seasons, Bonds never threw a single inning. That doesn’t diminish his greatness — it’s simply the nature of the debate.
Ohtani’s career pitching line stands at 39-20 with a 3.00 ERA and a 1.08 WHIP. His 11.4 strikeouts per nine innings would be the best mark in baseball history if he accumulated enough innings to qualify. Roberts sees those numbers up close every day. That’s exactly why his opinion carries more weight than any analyst who never wore a uniform.
Why the Timing of This Moment Matters
Roberts’ comments didn’t come at Ohtani’s peak. The Dodgers were swept 4-0 by the Milwaukee Brewers in the 2026 NLCS, with Ohtani playing through injuries to both his right bicep and left knee. Greatness, in this case, coexisted with defeat.
This isn’t the first time Roberts has gone on record, either. Back in January 2026, during MLB Network’s ‘Shohei Day,’ he already called him «the greatest player to ever put on a uniform.» The ‘6-1-1’ podcast is the more explicit version — because for the first time, Roberts named Bonds directly as the benchmark.
On November 12, the 2026 NL MVP is announced, with Ohtani on the ballot alongside Pete Crow-Armstrong and Brice Turang. A win would give him four career MVPs — still well behind Bonds’ seven, but with one difference Bonds’ trophies never had: not a single one came with a pitching start on the résumé.

